Tuesday, July 29, 2014 - Loading…

Published: Tuesday, 11/13/2012 - Updated: 1 year ago

5 found dead in West Toledo; police suspect murder-suicide

3 children, 2 adults in car in garage; authorities cite custody battle

BY TAYLOR DUNGJEN AND MARK REITER
BLADE STAFF WRITERS
Authorities respond to a report of carbon monoxide poisoning on Harvest Lane in Toledo. Authorities respond to a report of carbon monoxide poisoning on Harvest Lane in Toledo.
THE BLADE/AMY E. VOIGT Enlarge | Buy This Photo

A Toledo woman and her son al­leg­edly con­spired to kill them­selves and three young chil­dren — her grand­chil­dren and his nieces and nephew — in or­der to pre­vent the chil­dren's par­ents from re­gain­ing cus­tody, po­lice the­o­rized on Mon­day.

Po­lice found the five fam­ily mem­bers — Sandy Ford, 56; Andy Ford, 32; Paige Hayes, 10; Logan Hayes, 7; and Mada­lyn Hayes, 5 — dead in­side of a car parked in­side the fam­ily's at­tached ga­rage at 5142 Harvest Lane on Mon­day af­ter­noon.

Po­lice were called by Randy Ford, 60, Mrs. Ford's hus­band, at 3:17 p.m. re­quest­ing a check on their wel­fare; po­lice and fire ar­rived at at 3:26 p.m.

Toledo po­lice Sgt. Joe Hef­fer­nan said the el­der Mr. Ford re­turned home from work Mon­day af­ter­noon and found notes from his wife, son, and grand­chil­dren.

He be­came “con­cerned” and tried to find his fam­ily, and then re­al­ized the ga­rage door was locked and “bar­ri­caded” from the in­side.

Toledo fire crews used a sledge­ham­mer to force en­try into the ga­rage where they found the five dead, along with two dogs and a cat. The breeds of the an­i­mals were not avail­able late Mon­day.

Po­lice said the five peo­ple and the an­i­mals were in a blue Honda Civic; hoses from the ex­haust of a truck parked in­side of the ga­rage were run into the back pas­sen­ger win­dow of the Civic.

Ac­cord­ing to po­lice, Mrs. Ford was the pri­mary care­giver for the three chil­dren; Andy Ford also lived at the home, neigh­bors said. The chil­dren’s par­ents are Chris­to­pher Hayes, 38, and Mandy Hayes, 35, of Syl­va­nia.

A tow truck carries a vehicle from the home on Harvest Lane where two adults and three children were found dead of carbon monoxide poisoning. A tow truck carries a vehicle from the home on Harvest Lane where two adults and three children were found dead of carbon monoxide poisoning.
THE BLADE/AMY E. VOIGT Enlarge | Buy This Photo

Ser­geant Hef­fer­nan said the par­ents were in the pro­cess of get­ting full cus­tody and po­lice be­lieve that was the mo­tive for the al­leged mur­ders and suicides. He said carbon monoxide poisoning was suspected as the cause of the deaths.

Dean Sparks, ex­ec­u­tive di­rec­tor of Lu­cas County Chil­dren Ser­vices, said Mon­day night that he did not im­me­di­ately have much in­for­ma­tion about the case, but did know that the chil­dren were placed in the Fords’ cus­tody in 2009.

He did not have any in­di­ca­tion that there were ever court pro­ceed­ings in­volved. Not speak­ing spe­cif­i­cally about this case, Mr. Sparks said that, some­times, a par­ent can give per­mis­sion for chil­dren to live with an­other rel­a­tive.

“It's a hor­ri­ble trag­edy,” Mr. Sparks said. He added that Chil­dren Ser­vices staff mem­bers were at the scene Mon­day — as is pro­to­col when a sus­pected ho­mi­cide in­volves a child — but he had not heard from them to learn more about what hap­pened.

Ser­geant Hef­fer­nan said he was also not pos­i­tive about why the chil­dren were in the cus­tody of the Fords, but be­lieved there was a “do­mes­tic” is­sue.

Toledo po­lice were called to the Harvest Lane home twice last week, Ser­geant Hef­fer­nan said. Po­lice were there on Tues­day for a do­mes­tic vi­o­lence re­port be­tween Mrs. Ford and her daugh­ter Mandy Hayes. Po­lice were there again Thurs­day for a cus­tody ex­change, Ser­geant Hef­fer­nan said.

Ser­geant Hef­fer­nan said that some­one from Syl­va­nia schools might have called Mrs. Hayes or her hus­band, Chris Hayes, on Mon­day to re­port that her chil­dren were not at school.

Mr. and Mrs. Hayes on Mon­day night turned away a Blade re­porter who went to their Syl­va­nia home to in­ter­view them.

Syl­va­nia Schools Su­per­in­ten­dent Brad Rieger said the chil­dren were en­rolled in White­ford Ele­men­tary. Paige was a fifth grader, Logan was in sec­ond grade, and Mada­lyn was in kin­der­gar­ten. Their sis­ter, Blake, 9, at­tends Hillv­iew Ele­men­tary.

“This is a trag­edy,” he said.

Mr. Rieger said coun­sel­ors and psy­chol­o­gists will be avail­able at the school to talk to stu­dents, par­ents, teach­ers, and staff, and will be avail­able for as long as they are needed.

“The loss of life, es­pe­cially of a young per­son, is such a trag­edy that words can­not even ex­press it. Our hearts go out to the fam­ily and also the White­ford school com­mu­nity as we wres­tle with this tragic loss,” he said.

Neigh­bors were shocked to learn about the deaths.

Just last week the three chil­dren were out­side with Andy Ford, help­ing him rake leaves, said neigh­bor Doug Hall, who lives across the street.

“Andy did the leaves … and the three kids were al­ways out there with him, drag­ging the tarp, run­ning the lit­tle sucker thing or what­ever,” Mr. Hall said, stand­ing in his door­way. “ … I mean, it seemed like they did ev­ery­thing with him. When he was out­side, they were out­side do­ing stuff with him, it didn't mat­ter what the weather was.”

Con­tact Tay­lor Dung­jen at:tdung­jen@the­blade.com, or 419-724-6054 or on Twit­ter @tdung­jen_blade.



Guidelines: Please keep your comments smart and civil. Don't attack other readers personally, and keep your language decent. If a comment violates these standards or our privacy statement or visitor's agreement, click the "X" in the upper right corner of the comment box to report abuse. To post comments, you must be a Facebook member. To find out more, please visit the FAQ.

Related stories


Points of Interest